Friday, September 11, 2009

HATRED AND STRIFE

"He's never had a job in his life, the dirt bag!"

I was startled both by the tone of his words and the contempt in his expression that erupted in the midst of a moment of what I thought was light hearted banter. It left me speechless wondering how an otherwise solid family man and church-goer could be overtaken by such vitriol.

You might think we were talking about some miscreant who had made the headlines from a recent police blotter. But no, he was reacting to my mentioning of the President of the United States. His expression was very similar to the one on Joe Wilson's (Republican Rep. South Carolina) face when he, by his own admission, lost all sense of decorum and disrupted the President's speech to a joint session of Congress embarrassingly blurting out, "You lie!", for all to hear. It was a new low in partisan politics for which, after being confronted by congressional leaders, he apologized to the dismay of many who think he's a hero.

It is abundantly clear that our national political conversation has ventured into some very dangerous territory. Opponents of President Obama, who have been removed from their accustomed seats of power by an electorate disgusted with their bungling in recent years, have decided that the only way they can influence the outcome of health care reform policy, is by cynically relying upon their media propagandists to whip their shrinking audience into hostile hysteria. It is a calculated and coordinated strategy that has infused the body politic with a toxicity from which we may never recover. Too many under the influence of this deadly elixir have surrendered to an irrational hatred that is driving them to believe that it would be better to destroy the country than allow the proposed reforms.

Of course, there is a reaping what you sow aspect to this for the democrats. When they were the minority, they too employed some very uncivil tactics to leverage their limited power. Of President Bush many of them shouted, "He's not our president!" It was no less an attempt to deligitimize him than the right wing efforts to discredit Obama currently in play. Such tactics should be off-putting to reasonable people and disqualify anyone using them as a credible source. That includes propagandists like Olberman, Maddow, Limbaugh and Hannity who make a living by keeping their followers emotionally worked up and reactionary with their spew.

We need a national time out. We need some training in civics. We need honorable statesmen and women to rise above the fray and show us how to have political debate without resorting to the eye gouging, biting cage fighting of our current debate. Leaders who will offer their opinions and make their case with reason and facts and graciously accept either victory or defeat when the votes are counted. Absent that our future looks sad.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Man what a bummer, I do not depend on you for teaching but in my new found independence of living in a church without walls I really thought we had found something special a few months ago as i discovered a blog about the very subject in which I had so much interest. Your views were very well worded and your opinion was right in line with where I was studying. I have kept up with this blog and watched for new post only to be disappointed with your political views coming forth in your blog. Please understand that I tend to agree with most of those views too but may I beg of you to continue to post of your walk of faith some of the time too, until then I will live off of the previous post. And please take this light hearted because this is how I meant it. Thanks

Anonymous said...

Stevo:

I, too, enjoy your excellent posts on spiritual matters. But I also enjoy reading your concerns about secular matters, like politics. Although I sometimes disagree with some of your conclusions, I find it difficult to question your knowledge and sincerity. By the way, those who insist that God makes a distinction between the sacred and the secular are missing the whole point. The whole point may be summed up in Paul's writings as found in Romans 13:1-7. As someone has said, "We Christians must not get so heavenly minded, we become no earthly good."

Anonymous said...

I find Wilson's outburst little more than distraction from the larger issue being discussed, really. There does seem to be a neurosis on the part of the media to assign some sociological diagnosis to a vocal minority but if one knows their history, our evolution beyond pistol duels at dawn remains intact.

As is mentioned, it's a bog-standard tactic to shout down the opposition. And while means don't justify ends necessarily, American Politics kinda rely on that firmament of coercion.

I just can't seem to get past the specifics of this debate though. I can't seem to get enthused about caring about how we should comport ourselves in this duscussion...not when some estimates talk about 14,000 people losing healthcare each day in my country. Not when wages have stagnated to the point that they were at in 1997 but healthcare costs will balloon in the next 7-10 years to what an orthodox consensus projects as >50% of the average American household income annually. Not when there're 30 million people who don't have any form of healthcare anyway. And certainly not when normal, hardworking, everyday Americans are going bankrupt and dying because of something that is less a healthcare system so much as a healthcare market that is incentivised for profit and not people.

Britian, Japan, Taiwan, Switzerland, Germany, Canada...all of these countries currently carry the value that people are more important than profit--and in most cases these systems operate at some specific disadvantage to their American counterpart--except for the citizens of those societies. They appear to be, in my view, worth it to their respective societies.

I would argue that there is great spiritual significance to this issue. And while I would argue that a great many of the more beneficent advances in American society have come about through the means of government rather than private interests, the government and it's engine: politics can be quite deleterious. Not unlike the church really.

So if one finds themselves a part of the presently fortunate majority where this issue is an abstract one and they have a modicum of social conscience, in lieu of commitment intellectually or physically, I would say pray. Pray for people who will lose their job and subsequently have no means to healthcare. Pray for people who won't get a much-deserved raise because insurance costs will not be shouldered by private entities alone. Pray someone will be stirred by God to action to help those who have not.

Personally, I'll suffer propagandists who endorse a system that infuses more fairness and more equality and does it with a conscience rather than one who indulges egregiously in preferential treatment for those with plenty or violating the Geneva Conventions.

Anonymous said...

Which is worse? A single Republican congressman, Joe Wilson, while still seated, shouting "You Lie!" to President Obama (2009)? Or virtually all Democrat congressmen jumping to their feet at least five times shouting "Boo!" to President Bush
(2006)? We report; you judge.